Submitting a research paper to an academic journal is an important milestone in the research and publication process. However, submission does not mean that a manuscript will immediately be accepted, reviewed, or published. After submission, the paper usually passes through several stages, including administrative checks, editorial screening, peer review, revision, and a final publication decision.

For researchers, PhD scholars, postgraduate students, and first-time authors, understanding these stages can make the waiting period easier to manage. It also helps authors respond appropriately to editorial communications, prepare revisions, and avoid mistakes that could delay publication.

Although the exact process differs across journals, publishers, disciplines, and article types, most academic journals follow a broadly similar workflow. Before submission, it is worth reviewing Common Mistakes to Avoid Before Submitting a Research Paper to a Journal to ensure your manuscript is fully prepared.

1. The Journal Sends a Submission Confirmation

Once you submit your manuscript through the journal's online submission system, you will generally receive a confirmation message or email. This confirms that the submission has been received by the system, but it does not mean that the paper has been accepted for publication.

The confirmation may include a manuscript identification number, the submitted article title, the corresponding author's details, and a link to the submission portal. Keep this information safe because you may need it when contacting the editorial office or checking the manuscript's progress.

At this stage, verify that the manuscript title and author details are correct, the corresponding author's email address is accurate, the submission system displays the correct files, any supplementary documents have been uploaded successfully, and the manuscript ID has been recorded for future correspondence.

If you do not receive a confirmation, check your spam folder and log in to the submission portal before contacting the journal. Some systems display successful submission status even when an automated email is delayed.

2. The Editorial Office Checks the Submission

The first formal stage is usually an administrative or technical check. Editorial staff examine whether the submission meets the journal's basic requirements before it proceeds to editorial assessment. This step is intended to identify missing information and formatting problems that could prevent the manuscript from being processed efficiently.

Common checks include whether the manuscript follows the journal's submission guidelines, whether the required title page, abstract, keywords, and declarations are included, whether the references and manuscript format meet the journal's requirements, whether all authors and affiliations have been entered correctly, whether the required ethics approval, consent statement, funding declaration, or conflict-of-interest statement has been supplied where applicable, whether figures, tables, supplementary files, and captions are present and usable, and whether the manuscript appears to fall within the journal's scope and article-type requirements.

The journal may also screen the manuscript for textual similarity or other publication ethics concerns. For guidance on this step, see our article on How to Check Plagiarism in an English Literature Research Paper Before Submission.

If information is missing, the editorial office may return the submission to the author for correction. This is often an administrative request rather than a rejection based on the quality of the research. For example, a paper may be returned because the author omitted a conflict-of-interest declaration or uploaded a manuscript without a required title page. Correcting the issue promptly can help the submission move forward.

3. The Editor Conducts an Initial Assessment

After the administrative checks, the manuscript is typically assigned to an editor. Depending on the journal, this may be an editor-in-chief, associate editor, handling editor, or another editorial professional.

The editor evaluates whether the paper is suitable for further consideration. This assessment commonly considers several factors.

Scope and relevance: Does the research fit the journal's subject area and readership?

Originality: Does the manuscript offer a sufficiently clear contribution to existing knowledge?

Research quality: Are the research question, methods, analysis, and conclusions appropriate for the article type?

Presentation: Is the paper organized clearly and written well enough for meaningful evaluation?

Publication ethics: Are there concerns involving authorship, originality, research ethics, or other relevant policies?

For an English literature paper, an editor might consider whether the manuscript advances a meaningful interpretation, engages critically with relevant scholarship, and fits the journal's literary or theoretical focus. For a scientific paper, the editor may place greater emphasis on the research design, methods, data, and significance of the findings.

The precise criteria vary, but the central question is whether the manuscript merits further evaluation by external reviewers.

4. The Manuscript May Be Rejected Before Peer Review

A manuscript can be rejected during initial editorial screening without being sent to external reviewers. This is commonly called a desk rejection or editorial rejection. Although receiving such a decision can be disappointing, it is a normal part of academic publishing.

Common reasons include the manuscript falling outside the journal's scope, the contribution not being sufficiently clear or significant for the journal, substantial weaknesses in the research design or argument, the paper not meeting the journal's expectations for originality or depth, writing or structure that makes the contribution difficult to evaluate, non-compliance with essential submission requirements, or limited journal space and a higher volume of suitable submissions than the journal can publish.

A desk rejection does not necessarily mean that the research has no academic value. A paper may be appropriate for another journal with a different readership, scope, or level of selectivity.

If the editor provides feedback, study it carefully before submitting elsewhere. Address substantive weaknesses rather than immediately sending the same manuscript to another journal. Authors should also check whether the submission has formally been declined before submitting it elsewhere. A manuscript should not be under simultaneous consideration by multiple journals unless the journals explicitly permit such an arrangement.

JCRELC Call for Papers

5. The Editor Invites Peer Reviewers

If the manuscript passes the initial assessment, the editor may invite external experts to review it. Peer reviewers are researchers with relevant subject knowledge. They assess the manuscript's strengths, weaknesses, originality, methodology, argument, and contribution to the field.

Finding appropriate reviewers can take time. Editors must identify experts who have the necessary knowledge and are willing and available to review the paper. Potential reviewers may decline invitations because of workload, conflicts of interest, unfamiliarity with the specific topic, or other professional commitments. The editor may then need to invite additional reviewers.

This explains why a manuscript can remain at a status such as "Editor Assigned," "Reviewer Invited," or "Under Review" for longer than expected.

Different journals use different review models. Single-anonymous review means reviewers know the authors' identities, but authors do not know who the reviewers are. Double-anonymous review means the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from each other as far as the process allows. Open peer review means reviewer identities, reports, or other review information may be disclosed, depending on the journal's policy.

Some journals also use editorial review, statistical review, or other specialist assessments in addition to standard peer review.

6. Reviewers Evaluate the Research Paper

During peer review, reviewers examine the manuscript and prepare reports for the editor. The review process varies by discipline and article type.

Reviewers may consider whether the research question is clearly defined, whether the paper engages adequately with existing literature, whether the methods or analytical approach are appropriate, whether the evidence supports the claims and conclusions, whether important limitations have been acknowledged, whether the manuscript offers a meaningful contribution, whether the writing and organization allow readers to understand the work, and whether relevant ethical or reporting requirements have been addressed.

For a literary research paper, reviewers may assess the originality of the interpretation, the use of primary texts, engagement with critical scholarship, theoretical consistency, and the strength of the textual analysis. For an empirical study, they may examine sampling, data collection, statistical analysis, reproducibility, and the interpretation of findings.

Reviewers typically provide comments and a recommendation to the editor. Their recommendations may include acceptance, revision, or rejection, but the editor makes the journal's final decision.

Not every invited reviewer will necessarily submit a report. The editor may make a decision after receiving the required assessments or may seek additional opinions when the reports conflict.

7. The Editor Sends a Decision

After considering the reviews and the manuscript, the editor communicates a decision to the corresponding author.

Accept means the journal has agreed to publish the manuscript, subject to any remaining formal requirements. Unconditional acceptance at the first decision is relatively uncommon in many peer-reviewed journals. Some administrative or production steps may still be required before publication.

Minor Revision means the editor believes the manuscript is potentially publishable but needs limited changes. These may include clarifying a point, correcting a reference, expanding a discussion, addressing a reviewer's concern, or improving presentation. Minor revision does not guarantee acceptance, but it generally indicates that the requested changes are expected to be relatively limited.

Major Revision means the journal considers the manuscript promising but requires substantial changes before it can make a final decision. Authors may need to strengthen the analysis, clarify the methods, engage with additional scholarship, address limitations, reorganize sections, or provide further evidence. A major revision can involve considerable work. It is not the same as acceptance, and the revised paper may be sent back to the original reviewers.

Reject means the editor decides not to publish the manuscript in the journal. The decision may follow initial screening or external peer review. Reasons may include insufficient originality, serious methodological or analytical weaknesses, limited fit, or concerns that cannot be resolved through revision.

Some journals may offer a transfer to another journal within the same publisher. A transfer offer is not the same as acceptance by the receiving journal; the destination journal will apply its own editorial process.

8. How to Respond to Reviewer Comments

If the journal requests a revision, the next step is to prepare a revised manuscript and a structured response to the reviewers. For a detailed walkthrough, consult How to Respond to Peer Review Comments: A Guide for Research Scholars.

Read the decision letter and all reviewer reports carefully. Separate the comments into categories such as major conceptual issues, methodological concerns, missing references, clarification requests, and minor editorial corrections.

A strong response generally includes three elements. First, acknowledge the comment by stating the concern clearly and responding professionally. Second, explain the action taken by describing how the manuscript has been changed and identifying the relevant section, page, paragraph, or line numbers when available. Third, justify any disagreement by explaining your reasoning respectfully and supporting it with appropriate evidence or scholarship.

For example, if a reviewer asks for a clearer explanation of a theoretical framework, the author should revise the relevant section and explain how the revision addresses the concern. If the author believes a suggested change would weaken the argument, the response should explain why the original approach has been retained rather than dismissing the comment.

Avoid emotional language, personal criticism, or vague statements such as "Done" without explaining what changed.

Submit all required files, including the revised manuscript, response letter, tracked-changes version, and any other documents specified by the journal.

9. The Revised Manuscript May Undergo Another Review

After resubmission, the editor examines the revisions and the response letter. Depending on the extent of the changes and the journal's procedures, the editor may make a decision directly or send the revised manuscript back to one or more reviewers.

Reviewers may assess whether the authors have addressed the earlier concerns adequately. They may identify new issues that become apparent after the original problems have been resolved. The possible outcomes include acceptance, another round of revision, or rejection.

For this reason, authors should treat every revision request seriously, even when the journal describes it as minor. A careful, complete response reduces the risk of further delays caused by overlooked comments.

When revising, preserve a clear record of the changes made. A response letter that maps each reviewer comment to a specific revision makes the editor's assessment easier.

10. Acceptance Is Followed by Publication Preparation

Once the editor accepts the manuscript, it generally enters the publisher's production process. Acceptance and publication are different stages. An accepted manuscript may require several additional steps before it appears online or in a journal issue.

Depending on the journal, these steps may include copyediting for language, consistency, and style; typesetting the manuscript into the journal's publication format; checking tables, figures, equations, references, and captions; preparing proofs for author review; completing copyright or publishing licence documents; confirming open-access arrangements and any applicable publication charges; and assigning publication metadata and a digital object identifier (DOI) where applicable.

Authors should review proofs carefully. This is generally the stage for identifying typesetting errors, incorrect author details, formatting problems, and other production mistakes. Major changes to the research content may require editorial approval.

Respond to proof queries within the stated deadline. Delays at this stage can postpone publication.

The article may first appear as an online-first or advance publication before being assigned to a particular issue. Other journals publish articles only after issue scheduling. Publication practices vary.

11. The Article Becomes Available to Readers

After production is complete, the article is published according to the journal's publication model. The paper may appear on the journal website, in an online issue, in a print issue, or through a combination of formats.

At this stage, the author should check the published version for accuracy and confirm that the title, author names, affiliations, abstract, references, figures, and supplementary materials appear correctly.

Once the article is published, researchers can share it through permitted channels, update academic profiles, and include the citation in their research records. Authors should follow the publisher's rules when sharing the accepted manuscript or published version. Open-access articles may have different sharing conditions from subscription-based publications.

Publication is also an opportunity to make the work easier to discover through appropriate academic profiles, institutional repositories, and professional networks, subject to applicable policies.

12. How Long Does the Journal Publication Process Take?

There is no fixed timeline for every academic journal. The total time depends on editorial workload, reviewer availability, the complexity of the manuscript, the number of revision rounds, and the journal's production schedule.

Stage What Happens Possible Source of Delay
Submission confirmation The system records the manuscript Technical issues or incomplete submission
Administrative checks Files and required declarations are reviewed Missing documents or formatting problems
Initial editorial screening The editor assesses suitability Editorial workload or reassignment
Reviewer selection Review invitations are sent Experts declining invitations
Peer review Reviewers evaluate the paper Reviewer workload or delayed reports
Editorial decision The editor considers the reports Conflicting reviews or further assessment
Revision Authors address the comments Extensive changes or author availability
Production The accepted paper is prepared for publication Proof corrections, permissions, or scheduling

Some journals complete parts of this process relatively quickly, while others take several months or longer. Multiple revision rounds can extend the overall timeline.

If the journal publishes median times to first decision, review, or publication, use those figures as a guide rather than a guarantee. Also check whether the stated metric includes desk rejections or measures only manuscripts sent for external review.

13. What Should Authors Do While Waiting?

Waiting for an editorial decision can be frustrating, especially for early-career researchers working toward a thesis deadline, academic milestone, or funding requirement. However, repeatedly emailing the editor or submitting the same manuscript elsewhere will not usually speed up the process.

Authors can use the waiting period productively by checking the manuscript status through the journal's submission system, keeping copies of submission confirmations and correspondence, continuing relevant literature searches and research activities, preparing for a possible revision by reviewing the paper's limitations, monitoring institutional or funding deadlines, and keeping contact information current in the submission system.

If the manuscript has remained at the same stage beyond the journal's stated timeline, or if there has been no update for an unusually long period, a polite inquiry to the editorial office may be appropriate.

Include the manuscript ID, title, submission date, and a brief request for a status update. Avoid sending repeated messages within short intervals unless the journal has requested additional information.

14. Common Mistakes to Avoid After Submission

Authors can unintentionally complicate the publication process by making avoidable mistakes after submitting their work.

Submitting the same paper to multiple journals: Most scholarly journals require exclusive consideration. Wait for a formal decision or withdraw the manuscript according to the journal's procedure before submitting it elsewhere.

Ignoring editorial emails: Requests for missing documents, corrections, or declarations should be addressed within the specified timeframe.

Assuming "Under Review" means acceptance is likely: A status label indicates a stage in the workflow, not the eventual outcome.

Treating reviewer criticism as a personal attack: Peer review evaluates the manuscript, not the author's personal worth. Focus on the substance of the comments.

Making changes without explaining them: A revised manuscript should be accompanied by a clear response letter when requested.

Missing revision deadlines: If more time is needed, contact the editor before the deadline and request an extension rather than allowing the deadline to pass without explanation.

Paying suspicious publication fees: Verify any fee request through the journal's official website and correspondence channels. A legitimate journal should clearly explain its charges and payment process.

Overlooking publication proofs: Errors in author names, affiliations, references, and figures can persist into the published article if proofs are not checked carefully.

15. How to Follow Up With the Editorial Office Professionally

A status inquiry should be concise, courteous, and specific. Before writing, check the submission portal and the journal's stated processing times.

A suitable email might read:

Subject: Request for Update on Manuscript [Manuscript ID]

Dear Editorial Office,

I hope you are doing well. I am writing to inquire about the status of my manuscript, "[Manuscript Title]," submitted to the journal on [Submission Date]. The manuscript ID is [Manuscript ID].

I understand that the editorial and peer-review process takes time, and I appreciate the efforts of the editorial team and reviewers. I would be grateful for any update you may be able to provide regarding the manuscript's current status.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Kind regards,
[Author Name]

Use this template only when a follow-up is appropriate. Replace all placeholders with accurate information and avoid implying that the journal has exceeded its timeline unless that is supported by the journal's own guidance.

The journey from submission to publication involves several distinct stages. The journal first confirms receipt, checks the manuscript, and assesses its suitability. If the paper progresses, external reviewers evaluate its quality and contribution. The editor then communicates a decision, which may involve acceptance, revision, or rejection.

For authors, the most effective approach is to understand the process, monitor communications, respond to feedback professionally, and comply with the journal's requirements. Although authors cannot control reviewer availability or editorial workload, they can improve their chances of a smooth process by submitting a well-prepared manuscript and handling each stage carefully. For additional guidance on preparing your manuscript, explore AD Publications' guide on editing your research paper.

A submission confirmation is the beginning of the editorial process, not the end of it. Patience, clear communication, and thoughtful revision are essential parts of academic publishing.

Continue Exploring Our Blog

We invite you to read more insightful articles from our blog to support your academic journey in English Literature, Cultural Studies, and Research Methodology: